B-172: Feigning Incompetence to Stand Trial: A Case Study of Selective Legal Deficits and Symptom Exaggeration
Abstract
Objective: This case was referred to evaluate competency to stand trial in a defendant presenting with reported cognitive limitations, psychotic symptoms, possible traumatic brain injury, and profound deficits in legal knowledge and engagement with counsel. The referral raised the question of whether the defendant’s apparent inability to understand proceedings and assist in his defense reflected genuine impairment or noncredible symptom presentation. Method/Data Selection: The defendant is an adult male with a history of special education, polysubstance use, and reported psychiatric symptoms, including hallucinations and posttraumatic stress disorder. The evaluation included a forensic clinical interview, administration of the Revised Competency Assessment Instrument (RCAI), review of correctional, educational, and psychiatric records, behavioral observations, and administration of the Structured Inventory of Malingered Symptomatology (SIMS). Results/Data Synthesis: On structured competency assessment, the defendant demonstrated marked deficits in factual and rational understanding, including inability to identify courtroom roles, plea options, or legal procedures despite extensive prior criminal justice involvement. In contrast, he provided detailed and coherent responses regarding personal history and substance use. Behavioral observations revealed intact orientation and linear thought processes without evidence of active psychosis. Longitudinal records showed substantial inconsistency in reported psychiatric symptoms, including shifting accounts of hallucinations. SIMS results were significantly elevated across domains (Total = 48), consistent with symptom exaggeration. The overall pattern reflected selective nonparticipation and noncredible presentation. Conclusions: Findings support a pattern of noncredible presentation and selective nonparticipation rather than a mental disease or defect impairing competency. This case highlights the importance of integrating behavioral, psychometric, and historical data in differentiating feigned incompetence from genuine impairment.