Differential Acceptance of AI Technology Types in Educational Contexts with a Focus on Ethical Sensitivity
Abstract
This study explores differences in acceptance attitudes toward artificial intelligence (AI) technologies in educational contexts, focusing on ethical sensitivity. AI technologies may elicit varying acceptance judgments depending on their functional purposes and ethical implications, and existing approaches that treat AI acceptance as a unidimensional attitude have notable limitations. Drawing on the Extended Technology Acceptance Model (E-TAM) as an interpretive framework, this study empirically examines how technology acceptance is shaped through a complex evaluative process involving tension between perceived usefulness and risk–ethics awareness. Data were collected from 646 participants, including students and teachers, through binary agreement/disagreement responses and open-ended justification statements on nine AI technology cases. Analyses included descriptive statistics on acceptance rates by technology type, chi-square tests with Cramer's V for group comparisons by learner type and gender, and category-based content analysis of open-ended responses. Results indicated that technologies with clear functional utility were accepted at relatively higher rates, whereas technologies associated with human dignity, life, or creativity—or heightened ethical sensitivity—showed markedly lower acceptance. Significant differences by learner type were found for most technologies, with moderate or larger effect sizes observed in several cases. Content analysis revealed that agreement responses were driven mainly by instrumental judgments of usefulness, while disagreement responses concentrated on risk and ethical concerns. These findings suggest that AI technology acceptance is structurally differentiated by ethical sensitivity and cannot be adequately explained by utility-centered models alone. Accordingly, AI literacy education in educational contexts should extend beyond functional use to encompass ethical value judgment competencies.