Ultrasound Evaluation of Varicoceles: A Closed-Loop Audit of Compliance With European Society of Urogenital Radiology Guidelines
Abstract
Objective: To evaluate ultrasound reporting practices for varicoceles at a district general hospital in London against the European Society of Urogenital Radiology Scrotal and Penile Imaging Working Group (ESUR-SPIWG) standards and measure the impact of a structured reporting intervention. Background: Varicoceles are common and may cause infertility and chronic scrotal discomfort. Ultrasound is the gold standard imaging modality for investigation. The ESUR-SPIWG guidelines, based on the Sarteschi grading system, mandate documentation of testicular volume, vein location and diameter (supine and erect), and duration of venous reflux. Previous audit data suggested poor compliance with these standards. Methods: Retrospective closed-loop audit of ultrasound reports for 40 patients per cycle, investigated for varicoceles (Cycle 1: July 2023; Cycle 2: October 2024). Data were extracted from the Picture Archiving and Communication System (PACS) and CERNER (electronic health records). Three key reporting criteria were assessed per ESUR-SPIWG guidelines. A structured reporting template was introduced as an intervention between audit cycles. Results: Full compliance with all three criteria improved from 0% in Cycle 1 to 22.5% (9/40 cases) in Cycle 2. Cases documenting at least one criterion increased from 47.5% (19/40) to 82.5% (33/40). While the intervention demonstrated improvement, substantial gaps in adherence remain. Conclusions: The implementation of a structured reporting template showed measurable improvement in ESUR-SPIWG compliance; however, current practice still falls well short of the 100% target. This represents an audit cycle requiring continued quality improvement efforts. Further initiatives, including in-person education, intranet-accessible reporting pathways, and sustained reinforcement, are necessary to achieve guideline compliance and improve clinical decision-making for varicocele management.