Integrating self-leadership and caring in primary nursing: a theory-building scoping review
Abstract
Primary nursing emphasizes continuity, accountability, and individualized care; however, its implementation in contemporary healthcare settings remains conceptually fragmented. Existing literature often examines structural, cognitive-behavioral, and relational-ethical dimensions of nursing practice in isolation, limiting understanding of how these elements may interact. This review aimed to synthesize the literature and develop a preliminary conceptual framework integrating self-leadership and caring within primary nursing. A scoping review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA-ScR guidance. Four databases (Scopus, PubMed, CINAHL, and Web of Science) were searched, supplemented by manual searching and backward and forward citation tracking. Eligible publications made a substantive contribution to at least one focal domain: primary nursing, self-leadership and related concepts, or caring and related relational-ethical concepts. Data were charted and thematically synthesized to identify patterns, conceptual relationships, and evidence gaps. Fifteen publications were included: five conceptual/theoretical papers, four qualitative studies, two quantitative cross-sectional studies, one quasi-experimental study, and three reviews. The synthesis identified five themes: primary nursing as a structural foundation of accountable practice; self-leadership as a cognitive-behavioral dimension of autonomous practice; clinical decision-making as an operational expression of practice; caring as a relational-ethical dimension; and fragmentation across domains. Higher-order synthesis positioned relational accountability as a candidate integrative mechanism linking structural responsibility, self-regulated autonomy, and relational engagement. This proposed mechanism was not empirically established by the included literature. This review proposes a preliminary conceptual framework integrating structural, cognitive-behavioral, and relational-ethical dimensions of nursing practice. The framework organizes potentially related constructs and generates propositions for empirical investigation. Its proposed relationships and outcomes require validation across diverse healthcare contexts. Not applicable.