PUFFER: Incremental Fuzzy Deduplication for Continuously Evolving Corpora

Abstract

Large language model training corpora grow through successive, often redundant releases, so each release must be deduplicated against both itself and the accumulated history. At trillion-token scale, this requires incremental ingestion, bounded resident memory, deterministic retry, and dataset-scoped lifecycle control without repeated corpus-wide rebuilding. We introduce PUFFER (Provenance-aware Updatable Fuzzy Filtering for Evolving Repositories), a MinHash-LSH fuzzy-deduplication pipeline built around two design choices. First, PUFFER stores each LSH band as immutable, dataset-tagged, memory-mapped sorted segments, enabling exact historical band-key membership checks without RAM proportional to corpus size. Second, T-fanout tiered compaction periodically merges segments to control screening fanout, trading lower query cost against additional index-maintenance writes while preserving membership decisions. Across N ingested keys and K equal-sized releases, PUFFER's cumulative maintenance cost is O(N log N log_T K), compared with Theta(KN) for repeated snapshot rebuilding. Dataset-tagged segments also support dataset-scoped withdrawal: removal is constant-time for uncompacted or protected datasets, while post-compaction withdrawal reconstructs only the affected merged segment, even if the original dataset is unavailable. In our implementation, PUFFER completed cumulative index-stage ingestion for one billion documents in about 1.75 hours in a single process, using 128 bytes per document for a 16-band index. A classical resident MinHash-LSH table required about 6.5 KB per document and exceeded a 900 GiB RAM cap. In a ten-hour comparison capped at one billion documents, PUFFER was 11x faster than LSHBloom and 35x faster than Milvus-LSH. PUFFER is deployed on more than 30 billion documents, and we release it as open-source software at https://github.com/Zyphra/puffer.