Skip to content
Preprint

Beyond a Bag of Features: Set-Level Instability in Sparse Autoencoders

Aug 2026 · 0 citations · 41 references
Computer Science

TL;DR

It is found that SAE activation sets do not recover human category boundaries or within-category typicality more faithfully than dense embeddings or residual-stream states, but instead track model-internal similarity structure.

Abstract

Shani et al. (2026) show that LLM representations broadly recover human category boundaries, while failing to reflect fine-grained typicality structure. Their analysis uses cosine similarity over dense model representations. We revisit their approach using overlap over active sparse autoencoder (SAE) latent sets as a more interpretable similarity measure. We first verify that this set-level measure is meaningful: SAE latent sets can recover union-like compositional structure in controlled toy models and induce semantically coherent neighborhoods in natural text. Extending the human-concepts analysis to SAE set similarities, we find that SAE activation sets do not recover human category boundaries or within-category typicality more faithfully than dense embeddings or residual-stream states, but instead track model-internal similarity structure. To probe this gap further, we study active latent sets under well-controlled semantic modifications, revealing a substantial mismatch between human judgements of conceptual change and change in the SAE active set. We interpret this as evidence that, outside idealised settings, SAE features do not compose via simple bag-of-features semantics.

View source

Similar papers

Preprint Aug 2026

Where Does Generative Difficulty Reside? An Empirical Study of Target Representations

The target representation defines the distribution an image generator must learn, yet it is often treated as an interchangeable interface. This assumption is particularly questionable for continuous masked generators, which combine contextual inference from visible tokens with conditional modeling of each missing token. We study raw pixels, SD-VAE latents and DINOv2 as well as MAE representation-autoencoder features within a unified masked autoregressive rectified-flow model. Under a shared ImageNet training budget, these spaces exhibit distinct optimization and inference regimes. DINOv2 converges fastest in both iterations and computation but benefits strongly from a wider local denoiser and direct context fusion. Pixels optimize substantially more slowly and require a different prediction, masking, and guidance configuration. MAE reconstructs images more faithfully and exhibits clear semantic clustering, yet produces generations substantially worse than DINOv2. The representations also respond differently to classifier-free guidance and occupy distinct precision-recall trade-offs. Together, our results show that compression, reconstruction fidelity, token dimensionality, and visible semantic clustering do not individually predict generative behavior. Instead, target representations redistribute difficulty across contextual modeling, per-token denoising, and inference-time distributional control.

Marcel Plocher, Bernhard Schölkopf, Andreas Geiger et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Jul 2026

When Structured Sparse Autoencoders Learn Consistent Concepts Across Modalities

A Structured Sparse AutoEncoder that enforces concept consistency from both semantic and spatial perspectives in the visual modality is proposed and introduced, and enhances neuronal monosemanticity by this visual structural prior.

Weiduo Liao, Yunqiao Yang, Ying Wei · 0 citations
#machine learning Preprint Jul 2026

Are Single-Token Sparse Autoencoder Features Causally Necessary? Layer-Depth and SAE-Family Effects

Sparse autoencoder (SAE) features are used to interpret and steer large language models, yet whether a feature's causal role is stable across SAE families remains untested. Single-token features that activate on one vocabulary item provide the diagnostic case where ground truth permits direct comparison. We analyze 3.9M features across six models and three SAE families using zero-ablation at full layer depth. Single-token features cluster 4.7x tighter in decoder space and concentrate in early layers (Layer 0 in GPT2-Small; L0-L4 in Gemma). Ablating them yields Benjamini-Hochberg-significant logit reductions in 178 of 208 full-layer conditions, with depth controlling whether damage cascades downstream or shapes the output directly. Cross-family causal differences exceed within-family scale effects: on the same base model, GemmaScope and BatchTopK features remain causally anchored, while LlamaScope features are locally redundant. The target token's rank recovers to within 2x baseline 96-98% of the time after the same ablation, and a controlled activation-function comparison reverses sign within the same model, leaving training recipe as the residual candidate. Cross-family interpretability claims are therefore sensitive to training methodology, not just activation function or scale.

Seonglae Cho, Zekun Wu, K. Costa et al. · 1 citation
Open access Aug 2026

DESS: A Robust Uncertainty Layer for Embedding-Space Models

DESS is introduced, a lightweight uncertainty layer that augments an existing embedding model with a predicted mean vector and an independent per-dimension spread vector that provides a modular, geometry-aware uncertainty layer for embedding-space models, provided its spread is calibrated to local embedding geometry.

Morten Grundetjern, J. Voigt, Per-Arne Andersen et al. · 0 citations
Book Open access Aug 2026

H4G: Unlocking Faithful Inference for Zero-Shot Graph Learning in Hyperbolic Space

Text-attributed graphs are widely used across domains, offering rich opportunities for zero-shot learning via graph-text alignment. However, existing methods struggle with tasks requiring fine-grained pattern recognition, particularly on heterophilic graphs. Through empirical and theoretical analysis, we identify an over-abstraction problem: current approaches operate at excessively large hyperbolic radii, compressing multi-scale structural information into uniform high-level abstractions. This abstraction-induced information loss obscures critical local patterns essential for accurate predictions. By analyzing embeddings in hyperbolic space, we demonstrate that optimal graph learning requires faithful preservation of fine-grained structural details, better retained by representations positioned closer to the origin. To address this, we propose H4G, a framework that systematically reduces embedding radii using learnable block-diagonal scaling matrices and Möbius matrix multiplication. This approach restores access to fine-grained patterns while maintaining global receptive ability with minimal computational overhead. Experiments show H4G achieves state-of-the-art zero-shot performance with 12.8% improvement on heterophilic graphs and 8.4% on homophilic graphs, confirming that radius reduction enables faithful multi-scale representation for advancing zero-shot graph learning.

Heng Zhang, Jin Huang · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Rewriting or Reweighting? A Geometric Account in Language Models

Behavior manifold analysis is introduced, which isolates behavior-specific geometry by selecting sparse behavior-associated coordinates and lifting them into low-dimensional local charts, and provides a unified framework for understanding the mechanistic distinction between the two objectives.

Juntong Wang, Shengkun Yang, Xiyuan Wang et al. · 0 citations