Skip to content
Open access

Optimal Design of Geometrically Nonlinear Steel Structures Using Advanced Analysis

Aug 2026 · Applied Sciences · Vol 16, pp. 8499 · 0 citations · 43 references

Abstract

Advanced analysis has been shown to improve material efficiency in statically indeterminate steel-framed structures compared with member-based linear elastic design methods. However, limited research has investigated its applicability to geometrically nonlinear steel structures where residual stresses are induced by the bending process. In this study, the material optimization potential of advanced analysis has been quantified for two arch-based structures by comparing the volume of steel required to satisfy the criteria of both the system and member-based analysis methods in accordance with AS 4100:2020. The two structures were analyzed using the finite element analysis software Strand7 (R3.1.6) and subjected to combined gravity and wind loading in alignment with the serviceability and ultimate limit states specified in AS 1170.0:2002. System behavior was analyzed through the Arc-length plastic zone method. The results indicate that in one of the arch-based structures, advanced analysis can improve material utilization by 8.1%. Provided that future research both validates the use of the reduced stiffness method for treatment of initial geometric imperfections and verifies system reliability factors for structures with curved geometries, advanced analysis presents a practical design method for this structure. Comparison of the two case studies found that advanced analysis has the potential to improve material efficiency only when linear elastic failure is governed by ultimate limit state criteria. It is therefore evident that the material optimization findings of this research cannot be generalized to all arch-based structures, as they are contingent upon the geometry of the model analyzed, the loading scenarios considered, and the deflection limits adopted.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Jul 2026

EXAMINING THE G+2 REINFORCED CONCRETE FRAME'S STRUCTURE USING STAAD.PRO

Reinforced concrete (RC) frame structures must undergo structural analysis as a first stage in their design to guarantee sufficient strength, stability, and serviceability when subjected to stresses. Engineers may now more efficiently and accurately model and analyze complicated structural systems in three dimensions because to advancements in structural analysis software. This research project details the STAAD-based structural analysis of a G+2 reinforced concrete frame. Professional V8i (SELECTseries 5) in action. Following the applicable Indian Standard standards, a three-dimensional analytical model was created with 87 structural members and 48 joints. The model accounted for the necessary material qualities, sectional dimensions, support conditions, and loads. All loads, whether dead or live, as well as the governing load combination of 1.5(DL + LL), were taken into account throughout the study. Support responses, bending moment, shear force, axial force, and vertical displacement were used to analyze the structural response. Selected STAAD results were used to confirm the computational model's correctness.Simplified manual computations grounded on classical structural analysis techniques were contrasted with Pro. The numerical model was shown reliable when the comparison revealed variances within acceptable engineering norms, with a maximum divergence of around 12%. All structural response characteristics fulfilled the serviceability standards defined in IS 456:2000, according to the study. According to the research, STAAD.Pro is a solid and efficient platform for conducting 3D analyses of reinforced concrete frame structures, which may greatly aid in engineering and structural design decisions.

JAKKANI CHAITHANYA, Mrs. A.V. ANJANI DEVI, Dr. B. SHARATH CHANDRA · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Finite Element Analysis of Mechanical Behavior of Steel Reinforced Concrete (SRC) Columns Designed by Different Methods

The design of integrated station-bridge structures is challenged by the coexistence of building codes based on Limit State Design (LSD) and railway codes using Allowable Stress Design (ASD). This study employs finite element analysis to compare the performance of Steel Reinforced Concrete (SRC) columns designed under these two philosophies. The results demonstrate the significant conservatism of the ASD method: When achieving the same safety margin, the ASD-designed column required 2.36 times the cross-sectional area, yielding an 89% higher axial capacity but a disproportionately small increase in shear strength, indicating material inefficiency. A subsequent parametric analysis identified steel strength as key to axial capacity and concrete strength as critical for shear capacity, with shear performance reaching its maximum at an axial compression ratio of 0.6. These findings quantify these behavioral differences, offering a basis for refining design methods and codes harmonization for such structural members.

Jia Tang, Lin-Li Duan, Nan Chen et al. · 0 citations
Open access Jul 2026

A practical tool for economical design of I-shaped steel beams: development and application for parametric study

Steel beams are efficient structural elements widely used in industrial buildings due to their remarkable strength and ductility characteristics. Despite numerous studies exploring the optimization of steel beam for cost-effective designs, the utilization of optimization within the construction industry remains rare. This scarcity can be attributed to the complexities associated with applying optimization algorithms and the limited understanding of the structural behavior of optimized designs. In light of these challenges, this study aims to leverage the immense computational power of artificial intelligence (AI), specifically the Evolutionary Algorithm (EA), to develop an innovative AI-driven spreadsheet-based tool for cost optimization of I-shaped steel beams. Additionally, a parametric study investigates the influence of various design variables on the optimized cost. The EA within the Solver tool of MS Excel is used to perform the optimization. Design variables are subject to strength and serviceability-related constraints in accordance with AISC 360–22. The effectiveness of the developed optimization approach is demonstrated by optimizing four steel beam design examples from the literature. It is found that up to 51% of the beam cost can be optimized by keeping the beam depth and steel grade as variables. The parametric study reveals that the optimal range for the beam depth varies depending on the steel grade used. Further, the trends obtained for beam cost with respect to other variables such as flange and web slenderness ratio, and beam depth provide valuable insights for structural engineers undertaking steel beam optimization in the future.

Rizwan Azam, M. Riaz, Rana Muhammad Junaid et al. · 0 citations
Open access Jul 2026

Structural optimization of a Vibrocat carriage using Finite Element Analysis

Structural failures caused by fatigue represent one of the main challenges in heavy industrial equipment operating under severe loading conditions. This study evaluates the structural performance of a Vibrocat head carriage subjected to a critical load of 200 kN through Computer-Aided Design (CAD) and Finite Element Analysis (FEA). The original geometry was reconstructed and numerically analyzed using SolidWorks Simulation, considering ASTM A36 structural steel and linear elastic material behavior. The initial results revealed a maximum Von Mises stress of 617.86 MPa and a safety factor of 0.40, confirming the occurrence of localized yielding and explaining the recurrent fatigue failures observed during operation. Based on these findings, the head mounting plate was redesigned and validated under identical boundary conditions. The optimized configuration reduced the maximum stress to 126.63 MPa and increased the safety factor to 1.97, maintaining the component entirely within the elastic regime. The proposed reinforcement proved technically feasible, economically viable, and capable of significantly improving structural reliability and operational safety.

Denilson de Campos Branco da Silva, Edgard Gonçalves Cardoso, L. C. da Silva et al. · 0 citations
2026

Comparative Analysis and Design of Tapered Section Used in Pre-Engineered Building

Pre-Engineered Buildings (PEBs) have emerged as an efficient alternative to conventional steel structures due to their optimized material usage, reduced self-weight, and faster construction. This study presents a comparative analysis and design of tapered sections used in PEB portal frames to evaluate the influence of rafter break point location on structural behaviour. Five different structural models were developed using STAAD.Pro with identical geometry, loading conditions, and design criteria in accordance with ARE 800:2007, IS 875, and ARE 1893:2016. Among the five models, Model I was designed strictly based on bending moment requirements, while the remaining models were configured with varying rafter break points without strict adherence to moment-based design. The analysis includes evaluation of key parameters such as frame weight, bending moment, and support reactions under dead, live, wind, and seismic loads. The results indicate that Model I achieves the minimum structural weight, demonstrating efficient material utilization, whereas Model IV provides improved overall structural performance with better force distribution. It is observed that variation in rafter break point significantly affects bending moment distribution and structural efficiency, while support reactions remain nearly constant across all models. The study concludes that bending moment-based design is essential for achieving economical and optimized PEB structures, while intermediate tapering configurations can enhance overall performance.

Trupti Nandanwar, Mahendra Umare, Pritam Kandikurwar et al. · 0 citations