Bridging the Implementation Gap: Artificial Intelligence in Periodontology from Proof-of-Concept to Clinical Governance—A Systematic Scoping Review with Evidence from Kazakhstan
Safe, effective AI integration in periodontology requires a phased approach: national multimodal databases, local clinical validation, certified workflow integration, continuous monitoring, population-level surveillance, and legal governance covering liability and insurance.
Abstract
Background/Objectives: Periodontitis, the sixth most prevalent disease worldwide, affects over 740 million people and disproportionately burdens transitional economies. Although artificial intelligence (AI)—including deep learning (DL) and machine learning (ML)—achieves high diagnostic accuracy in research settings, a gap persists between proof-of-concept and real-world deployment, especially where regulation is nascent, as in Kazakhstan. This scoping review maps global evidence on AI for periodontal diagnosis, risk prediction, and monitoring; evaluates governance frameworks; and proposes a contextualised implementation model for emerging health systems. Methods: Following PRISMA-ScR and PRISMA 2020 guidance, PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, Embase, and Cochrane Library were searched (January 2015–April 2025), supplemented by regulatory and grey literature; ten additional sources published after the search closure were subsequently identified through citation checking and expert peer review during revision, as a targeted amendment rather than a re-executed database search. Forty sources in total (29 peer-reviewed empirical and review studies plus 11 regulatory, grey literature, and patent documents) met the inclusion criteria and were charted thematically. Results: Two dominant paradigms emerged: image-based DL (convolutional neural networks and Vision Transformers), achieving 73–98.6% accuracy for radiographic bone loss detection, and ML-based non-clinical screening using patient-reported data and salivary biomarkers. Digital tools (smart toothbrushes, chatbots, and IoT platforms) form a third domain. Performance dropped consistently on external validation, reflecting data quality and sample size constraints. Regulatory analysis showed convergence of the EU AI Act, U.S. FDA framework, WHO guidance, and Kazakhstan’s AI Development Concept (2024–2029) around risk-based classification, transparency, and post-market surveillance. Conclusions: Safe, effective AI integration in periodontology requires a phased approach: national multimodal databases, local clinical validation, certified workflow integration, continuous monitoring, population-level surveillance, and legal governance covering liability and insurance. Kazakhstan’s evolving regulatory and digitalisation strategy may offer a context-specific case for evaluating AI adoption pathways across Central Asia and transitional economies, pending prospective validation.
Nepal’s AI-health landscape has progressed from conceptual awareness toward early diagnostic validation and deployment, particularly in imaging-based screening and medical education, yet the current evidence remains insufficient for conclusions about scale-up, safety, equity, cost-effectiveness, or system-wide impact.
Prajjwol Luitel, Nischal Neupane· Digital Health· 0 citations
A scoping review following the PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR) framework found AI shows promise in augmenting mpox preparedness, prediction, prevention, and surveillance, but most tools remain at a proof-of-concept stage.
M. Sannathimmappa, Vinod Nambiar, S. Satti· Discover Public Health· 0 citations
A review examines how free full-text PubMed literature describes the real-world implementation of AI in healthcare and identifies the technical, organizational, ethical, and social conditions that shape adoption.
Jagoda Pałubska, Oliwer Műller, Zuzanna Rafałowska et al.· International Journal of Inn...· 0 citations
Purpose of the Study: Artificial intelligence (AI) has expanded rapidly across dentistry over the past decade, yet the field's global intellectual structure, collaboration patterns, and thematic evolution remain unevenly mapped. This study examines the scientific structure, collaboration networks, and thematic evolutio...
Hossein Boustani Hezarani, Dilek Uslu· Journal of international hea...· 0 citations
This narrative review synthesizes evidence on clinical AI methods, applications, implementation, evaluation, evaluation, and sustainability in hospitals and proposes institutional efficacy as the warranted and revisable hospital-level judgment that an AI-enabled service configuration can generate and sustain patient-ce...
Introduction: Artificial intelligence (AI), particularly convolutional and artificial neural networks, is being applied to image interpretation, decision support and outcome prediction in endodontics. Since the scoping review by Asgary in 2024, the literature has expanded to include large language models, microrobotics...
Mohammed Muzaffar Khan, Ridhi Karwal, Navi Bansal et al.· International Journal of Enh...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.