Skip to content
Open access

From real-world experience to precision prescribing of antidepressants: a machine-learning analysis of clinicians' treatment choices.

Sep 2026 · European Neuropsychopharmacology · Vol 113, pp. 113882 · 0 citations · 32 references
Medicine

TL;DR

This study examined whether psychiatrists' routine prescribing decisions could be used to identify practice-grounded patterns supporting precision-oriented treatment selection, and found that similarity-based models may provide a more conceptually coherent approach.

Abstract

Antidepressant prescribing in major depressive disorder is guided by evidence-based recommendations, but real-world decisions often rely on clinical judgment, previous experience, and case-based reasoning. This study examined whether psychiatrists' routine prescribing decisions could be used to identify practice-grounded patterns supporting precision-oriented treatment selection. We analyzed 428 real-world clinical cases of major depressive disorder collected from psychiatrists across several Italian centers. Thirty-one socio-demographic and clinical variables were used as input features, while prescriptions for 16 antidepressants were the output variables. Five supervised machine-learning models, including logistic regression, multilayer perceptron, decision tree, LightGBM, XGBoost, were compared with a similarity-based approach to retrieve clinically comparable cases. Across supervised models, predictive performance was limited, mostly close to random chance. In contrast, the similarity-based approach showed appreciable concordance across comparable cases. At the individual-antidepressant level, full concordance emerged in 223 cases (52.84%), while no concordance within the 10 nearest neighbors was observed in 104 cases (24.64%), increasing to 318 cases (75.36%) for full concordance at a pharmacological-class level. The limited performance of supervised models should not be viewed as algorithmic failure, but as evidence of a mismatch between conventional predictive learning and the nature of real-world psychiatric prescribing data. Conversely, similarity-based models may provide a more conceptually coherent approach, since it is closer to psychiatric analogy-based reasoning, in which clinicians often draw on previous similar cases rather than applying deterministic rules. The higher pharmacological class concordance may reflect guidelines that usually frame recommendations by therapeutic class, while preserving flexibility in the selection of individual agents.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Aug 2026

Prediction in routine care: a naturalistic comparison of clinicians and a machine learning model for patients receiving treatment for generalised anxiety disorder.

OBJECTIVE Approximately half of patients with generalised anxiety disorder (GAD) do not recover following psychological treatment. Accurate prognostic judgement may support clinical decision-making and planning. This study compared the predictive accuracy of clinicians and a validated machine learning model and examine...

H. Delamain, L. Dolby, H. Partington et al. · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Adverse-effect burden as the dominant correlate of antidepressant non-adherence in major depressive disorder: insights from a multicentre machine-learning analysis.

BACKGROUND Non-adherence to antidepressants contributes to relapse and recurrence in major depressive disorder (MDD). Existing risk-prediction models are drawn largely from chronic conditions in high-income settings; none exist for Pakistani outpatient psychiatry. METHODS We analysed cross-sectional, patient-reported...

S. Riaz, Fazli Khuda, A. Nasim et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

525. Precision psychiatry in practice: mechanism, algorithms, and clinical choice

Abstract Background Despite the availability of more than 25 licensed antipsychotics worldwide, prescribing decisions remain constrained by oversimplified classifications and fragmented guideline recommendations. The conventional dichotomy between “typical” and “atypical” antipsychotics fails to capture meaningful diff...

R. McCutcheon · 0 citations
Review Aug 2026

From prediction to decision: prediction-based decision rules and target trial emulation in ADHD.

More than 100 prediction models have been developed to support the diagnosis, prognosis, or treatment of ADHD, yet none has reached routine clinical practice. In this Personal View, we argue that an important reason for this implementation gap is the absence of clearly defined prediction-based decision rules-formalised...

M. Garcia-Argibay, S. Faraone, Zheng Chang et al. · 1 citation
Open access Jul 2026

Predicting Dropout in Psychotherapy for Major Depressive Disorder: A Machine Learning Approach to Identifying At-Risk Patients.

Five key predictors of dropout emerged: younger age, unemployment, a higher number of comorbid Axis I disorders, absence of a partner, and moderate depression severity, and all models showed reduced performance during external validation.

S. Bremer-Hoeve, S. V. van Bronswijk, A. Beekman et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Real-World Antidepressant Prescribing Patterns and Comparative Safety Outcomes of Commonly Prescribed Antidepressants in Patients with Depressive Disorder: A Multicenter OMOP-CDM Study

Background/Objectives: Real-world antidepressant use for depressive disorder varies across clinical settings. This study aimed to characterize prescribing pathways and evaluate the comparative safety of frequently prescribed antidepressants in a large multicenter cohort with newly diagnosed depressive disorder. Methods...

Jungha Min, Sueun Shin, Sohyeon Park et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.