Skip to content

Critical Reflections and Third Spaces in the Secondary English Classroom

Sep 2026 · Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy · Vol 70 · 0 citations · 12 references

Abstract

This article examines a pedagogical shift in how student writing is conceived, from a solitary, evaluative demonstration of finished argument toward a recursive, dialogic, collaborative process of knowledge construction. This shift is enacted through the Critical Reflection, a short‐form, open‐ended, frequently‐executed writing assignment grounded in Homi Bhabha's hybrid third spaces and Mikhail Bakhtin's polyphonic chronotopes. Through a practitioner‐research analysis of student submissions, peer annotations, and meta‐commentaries from a single secondary classroom, the author traces how this approach fostered syntactic fluidity, theoretical integration, a shared class lexicon, and productive uncertainty, alongside the uneven outcomes and tensions that accompanied it. The Critical Reflection emerges as a pedagogical third space in which most students moved from passive reporters toward active critics, offering transferable principles for reconceiving writing as dialogic and recursive.

View source

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Self-Reflection of Student Through of a Dialogic Inquiry Approach in Writing

Writing instruction in EFL contexts involves not only the development of language proficiency but also the ability to evaluate ideas, revise drafts, and recognize strengths and weaknesses in the writing process. However, many students still experience difficulties in engaging in critical and sustained self-reflection....

Azhah Nurlita Maulin, W. Kusriandi, Diana Rahmawati Rozak · 0 citations
Conference Open access Aug 2026

Self-Publishing as Practice-Based Inquiry in Japanese University EFL

This paper reports a narrative inquiry into the process of writing, self-publishing, and revising a textbook for first-year Japanese university students studying English as a Foreign Language. Developed in response to dissatisfaction with commercially produced materials, the textbook adopted an approach based on extend...

Roy Kemm · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Toward AI-Scaffolded Pedagogical Stylistics: A Conceptual Framework for Bridging the Language–Literature Divide in L2 English

Literature has a long-standing place in second-language (L2) English teaching because it offers learners language that is rich, patterned, and affectively charged, and pedagogical stylistics provides a principled way of turning that language into learning by having students notice the choices through which literary eff...

Yasir Hazim Qasim · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

The Effectiveness of Critical Writing Feedback as Pedagogical Responses in English Writing Classrooms: Evidence from Bangladesh Secondary Schools Education

Writing feedback is essential because it helps learners recognize weaknesses, refine ideas, and revise texts purposefully. Yet secondary-school feedback often remains focused on surface errors rather than argument, organization, evidence, and critical engagement. This study investigated how critical writing feedback wa...

Thoric Ahmad, Ahmad Javed Hassan, Mohammed Meraj et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.