Skip to content
Open access

Promoting healthy families: a three-arm randomized controlled trial of Triple P and Circle of Security-Parenting versus treatment-as-usual for families with young children (2-6 years).

Oct 2026 · Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines · 1 citation · 73 references
Medicine

TL;DR

Triple P demonstrated selective short-term benefits relative to TAU across child behavioral and parenting outcomes, with sustained effects limited to parental attributions, and COS-P showed no measurable effects relative to TAU.

Abstract

Background

Parenting programs grounded in social learning (SL) and attachment theory are widely implemented, yet few trials have directly compared their effects across multiple parenting domains in community contexts. This study examined the relative effectiveness of an SL-based program (Triple P - Level 4 Group) and an attachment-based program (Circle of Security - Parenting, COS-P) against treatment-as-usual (TAU) when delivered online through community agencies.

Methods

A three-arm randomized controlled trial was conducted across four community organizations in Ontario, Canada. Caregivers of children aged 2-6 years (N = 502) were randomized (1:1:1) to Triple P, COS-P, or TAU. Primary outcomes were child behavioral difficulties (SDQ-Total) and parental overreactivity with post-intervention, 6-, and 12-month follow-up. Secondary outcomes included parental attributions, parenting stress, and caregiver mental health. Analyses followed an intention-to-treat framework using mixed-effects models (ClinicalTrials.gov #NCT04702191).

Results

Relative to TAU, Triple P demonstrated significant short-term reductions in emotional symptoms and conduct problems, and immediate improvements in hostile and helpless parenting and anxiety; however, most between-group effects did not persist beyond post-intervention. Effects on total child behavior problems at 12 months were no longer significant after correction for multiple testing. Improvements in parental attributions were sustained at 12 months. COS-P differed from TAU on only one outcome, at one time point. Within-group improvements in child behavior, dysfunctional parenting, and caregiver mood were observed in TAU, with COS-P and Triple P showing similar trends. Exploratory analyses suggested broader benefits for Triple P relative to COS-P.

Conclusions

Triple P demonstrated selective short-term benefits relative to TAU across child behavioral and parenting outcomes, with sustained effects limited to parental attributions. COS-P showed no measurable effects relative to TAU. These findings highlight the importance of behavioral management and self-regulation components and point to the need for further research examining contextual moderators, maintenance strategies, and sustainable delivery approaches, including digital formats.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Sep 2026

Research Review: No robust effects of Circle of Security-Parenting (COSP) on parenting, parents, or children - a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.

BACKGROUND Circle of Security-Parenting (COSP) is one of the most popular attachment-based preventive support programs for parents and children. More than 50,000 participants from different (para)professional disciplines have been trained in the formal COSP™ protocol. METHODS In a preregistered meta-analysis and synt...

M. Bakermans-Kranenburg, Megan Galbally, Erinn Hawkins et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Is it Time to Rethink a Common Approach in the Study of Parent Participation in Parenting Interventions? (Null) Findings from a Large-Scale Cluster Randomised Trial.

The real-world impact of evidence-based parenting programs depends on their ability to engage parents and families. Yet, knowledge about the facilitators and barriers of participation remains limited. A common approach to study parent participation is conducting secondary analyses of clinical trial data, which often yi...

Tian-Yi Ma, Alina Morawska, Caitlyn Morse et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

A coherent family support model (Co-Fam) for preventing and treating childhood overweight and obesity: protocol for a randomized hybrid type 2 effectiveness-implementation trial

Swedish child healthcare involves school health services, primary healthcare, and pediatric clinics. Family-based programs addressing child diet, eating behavior, parental feeding practices and physical activity show promise for preventing and treating overweight in children 2–12 years, but organizational gaps hinder c...

Ida Berdman, A. Ek, P. Nowicka et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Group-Based Parenting Programs for Single-Parent Families: A Systematic Review of the Literature

Single-parent families often face cumulative social and economic vulnerabilities that can influence parenting and increase the use of harsh or violent disciplinary strategies. Parenting programs have the potential to strengthen positive parenting practices and prevent violence against children. However, little is known...

Elisa Leithold, E. Altafim, Camila Regina Lotto et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Optimising indicated prevention for child anxiety and depression: A 12-month follow-up for cluster-randomised factorial 2 x 2 x 2 trial.

BACKGROUND Early intervention can reduce the burden of internalising problems for children and adolescents, yet access remains limited. The field must ensure preventive interventions that are both durable and scalable. One promising approach is developing interventions that are less resource- intensive yet retain compo...

Carina Lisøy, S. Neumer, T. Waaktaar et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

A Quasi-Experimental Trial of Digitally Supported Strength-Based Parenting Program in Hong Kong

Purpose: Strength-based parenting (SBP) is a promising parenting approach that may promote parental and children's well-being, yet its use in Chinese contexts is underexplored. This study developed and evaluated a localized, digitally supported SBP intervention for Hong Kong families. Method: Seventy-nine parent–c...

Ding-Hua Jia, Xiao-Yu Zhuang, D. F. K. Wong et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.