Skip to content
Review Open access

Research Review: No robust effects of Circle of Security-Parenting (COSP) on parenting, parents, or children - a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.

Sep 2026 · Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines · 0 citations · 41 references
Medicine

Abstract

Background

Circle of Security-Parenting (COSP) is one of the most popular attachment-based preventive support programs for parents and children. More than 50,000 participants from different (para)professional disciplines have been trained in the formal COSP™ protocol.

Methods

In a preregistered meta-analysis and synthesis of all eight randomized trials (N = 1,094 families), we examined COSP's efficacy on caregivers' parenting (sensitive parent-child interactions, reflective functioning, and parenting attitudes), on parent mental health outcomes (stress, depression, and anxiety), and on child attachment security and behavior problems.

Results

We found an overall nonsignificant effect size of Cohen's d = 0.142 (SE = 0.089; p = .154, 95% Confidence Interval -0.068, 0.353, 95% Prediction Interval -0.444, 0.729), in a homogeneous set of studies. The pooled effect sizes of the parenting, parent, and child domains did not differ from each other or from zero. Cluster-robust inference tests showed converging (nonsignificant) results. The majority of the randomized studies (82%) were identified with some concerns about risk of bias.

Conclusions

We conclude that the evidence for COSP efficacy does not keep pace with the uptake of COSP in professional practice and policy.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

Promoting healthy families: a three-arm randomized controlled trial of Triple P and Circle of Security-Parenting versus treatment-as-usual for families with young children (2-6 years).

Triple P demonstrated selective short-term benefits relative to TAU across child behavioral and parenting outcomes, with sustained effects limited to parental attributions, and COS-P showed no measurable effects relative to TAU.

Andrea Gonzalez, G. Meléndez-Torres, Divya Joshi et al. · 1 citation
Open access Oct 2026

A Quasi-Experimental Trial of Digitally Supported Strength-Based Parenting Program in Hong Kong

Purpose: Strength-based parenting (SBP) is a promising parenting approach that may promote parental and children's well-being, yet its use in Chinese contexts is underexplored. This study developed and evaluated a localized, digitally supported SBP intervention for Hong Kong families. Method: Seventy-nine parent–c...

Ding-Hua Jia, Xiao-Yu Zhuang, D. F. K. Wong et al. · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Validation of the Short Form of the Integrated Evaluation of Parenting Attitude and Stress (IE-PAS): Focusing on Parenting Characteristics

Purpose: This study developed a short form of the parent domain of the IE-PAS (106 items, 13 subscales of the Parenting Foundation Scale and Parenting Attitude Scale) and examined its reliability and validity. Method: Samejima's graded response model was applied to data from 1,241 parents of children aged 3~16. Items...

Hye-Jin Noh, Tai-Hui Han, Sang-Hwang Hong · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Parenting engagement in the preschool parenting period: development of a brief scale and evidence from a working-parent demands-resources model.

Research on working parents has focused primarily on strain, work-family conflict, and burnout, with less attention to positive motivational processes in parenting. Drawing on engagement theory and the demands-resources framework, this study developed and validated the Parenting Engagement Scale (PES) and assessed pare...

Momoko Kobayashi, Hiroshi Ikeda · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Predictors of Parenting Stress in a National Matched Sample of Children With/Without Chronic Pain

Parents of children with chronic health conditions demonstrate elevated parenting stress. Literature has focused on how parenting behaviors amplify their child’s pain; less research has examined parents’ emotional needs. Using national data (USA), this study examined parent and child factors that may influ...

Alison Vrabec, Katherine M. Kidwell · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Is it Time to Rethink a Common Approach in the Study of Parent Participation in Parenting Interventions? (Null) Findings from a Large-Scale Cluster Randomised Trial.

The real-world impact of evidence-based parenting programs depends on their ability to engage parents and families. Yet, knowledge about the facilitators and barriers of participation remains limited. A common approach to study parent participation is conducting secondary analyses of clinical trial data, which often yi...

Tian-Yi Ma, Alina Morawska, Caitlyn Morse et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.