The optic nerve sheath diameter on ultrasound can only be used as a marker of intracranial pressure after comparison with a gold standard
TL;DR
It was concluded that ONSD measurement is a reliable method for identifying patients with elevated ICP and Cerebral computed tomography and clinical presentation are not sufficient standards for assessing ICP.
Abstract
We read with interest the article by Çelik et al. on the validity of measuring the optic nerve sheath diameter (ONSD) using transorbital ultrasound to assess intracranial pressure (ICP) in 50 patients with suspected elevated ICP 1 . The ONSD was higher in the patients than in the control group and correlated with mortality as well as with scores such as the Glasgow Coma Scale, Full Outline of Unresponsiveness, Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II, and Sequential Organ Failure Assessment 1 . It was concluded that ONSD measurement is a reliable method for identifying patients with elevated ICP 1 . The study is interesting, but some points require further clarification. The first point is that the conclusions drawn should be viewed with caution, as the ultrasound results were not compared to a gold standard for determining ICP 1 . The gold standard for measuring ICP in the intensive care unit is an ICP probe inserted through a burr hole 2 . Cerebral computed tomography and clinical presentation are not sufficient standards for assessing ICP. As long as the assessment of ICP via ONSD measurement is not compared to the gold standard, it remains uncertain whether ONSD measurement actually reflects elevated ICP. Second, ONSD depends not only on ICP but also on several other factors 3 . These include age, gender, posture, the collagen and elastin content of the sclera and the optic nerve sheath, the stiffness of the surrounding tissue, intraocular pressure, intra-orbital venous congestion, intraorbital pressure, intraorbital geometry, the morphology of the optic nerve, the morphology of the eyeball (curvature, radius, scleral thickness), blood pressure, respiratory status, altitude, coughing, upper body