Skip to content
Open access

Detecting Self-Repairs from Spontaneous Speech with Prompt Ablation Across LLMs and Fine-Tuned Encoder

Aug 2026 · medRxiv · 0 citations
Medicine

TL;DR

This work compares the capability of generative LLMs under a five-condition prompt ablation against a fine-tuned DistilBERT token classifier at detecting self-repairs and suggests that a locally deployable encoder, given sufficient in-domain annotation, is a more plausible route to clinical self-repair detection than scaling model size or prompt complexity.

Abstract

Self-repairs, in-utterance revisions in which a speaker abandons and reformulates their speech, are a promising interpretable marker for speech-based cognitive screening. Detecting them automatically is difficult because a self-repair is defined by its relationship to surrounding speech rather than by fixed lexical cues. On the DementiaBank ADReSS corpus, we compared the capability of generative LLMs under a five-condition prompt ablation against a fine-tuned DistilBERT token classifier at detecting self-repairs. GPT-5 performed best (test F1 = 0.73) and was largely insensitive to prompt design, whereas the LLaMA (open-weight alternative) was both weaker and far more prompt-sensitive (test F1 = 0.47). DistilBERT, nearly 100 times smaller, matched the open-weight LLM at a fraction of the computational cost. These results suggest that a locally deployable encoder, given sufficient in-domain annotation, is a more plausible route to clinical self-repair detection than scaling model size or prompt complexity.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Preprint Aug 2026

Iterative Self-Learning for Expressive Text-to-Speech Synthesis

Expressive text-to-speech (TTS) systems that use explicit conditioning labels provide direct and interpretable control over expressive attributes, in contrast to reference-based or prompting-based approaches, but require labeled data. Obtaining these labels at scale is costly and time-consuming, yet no prior semi-supervised framework addresses this specific bottleneck. Existing semi-supervised TTS methods instead target scarcity of paired speech-text data or transcriptions. To address the scarcity of expressive labels, we propose an Iterative Self-Learning (ISL) framework for expressive TTS, built on Invert-Classify, a classifier-free method that recovers discrete expressive labels by inverting a frozen generative model. The framework iteratively pseudo-labels unlabeled speech using the current model, retrains on the combined labeled and pseudo-labeled data, and repeats, progressively refining label quality and synthesis. We validate on two expressive tasks, word-level prominence and utterance-level emotion, across multiple low-resource data splits. We find that iterative refinement can improve pseudo-label accuracy over single-pass baselines. Furthermore, we observe that these improvements in pseudo-labeling of expressivity translate to gains in expressive label adherence and synthesis quality, confirmed by objective metrics and human listening tests. In the most data-scarce conditions, ISL-trained models outperform single-pass pseudo-labeling and further approach fully supervised performance, demonstrating that gradient-based ISL is an effective solution to expressive label scarcity in low-resource TTS.

Nicholas Sanders, G. Henter, Simon King et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Evaluating Pre-trained Speech Encoders for Spontaneous Speech Detection and Out of Domain Synthetic Speech Generalisation in Indic Languages

Transformer-based models have shown strong accuracy in distinguishing spontaneous from scripted speech and natural from synthetic speech, but these results are established on a narrow set of well-resourced language benchmarks and have not been extended across Indic languages, nor has embedding geometry been used to explain encoder behaviour or deepfake generalisation failure. We address these gaps by evaluating five frozen transformer encoders, AST, Vaani-FastConformer, Wav2vec2, Whisper and BEATs, across 22 Indic languages, and by conducting a multi-system TTS generalisation experiment across four TTS models. Beyond accuracy, we present language isolation probing and centroid proximity analysis. Probing reveals an encoder-dependent trade-off between language-discriminability and spontaneity detection. Centroid analysis shows that out-of-domain generalisation is predicted by a training system's proximity to unseen TTS embeddings, not its distance from natural speech, a finding with direct implications for training data selection in real-world deepfake detectors.

Varun Rai, Pavan Kumar, Sujith Pulikodan et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Motor, Cognitive, or Corpus? What Survives Cross-Lingual Transfer in Speech-Based Parkinsons Disease Detection

Self-supervised learning (SSL) speech representations achieve strong performance for Parkinson's disease (PD) detection within individual corpora. However, it remains unclear whether these models capture disease-related characteristics or exploit dataset-specific confounds, particularly since most SSL backbones are pretrained exclusively on healthy speech. To investigate this question, we perform a layer-wise analysis of nine SSL speech backbones using a low-capacity logistic regression probe across three languages. We structure the evaluation as multiple scenarios that progressively introduce distribution shifts in participant identity, recording conditions, language, and pathology. Our results reveal two key findings. First, layer selection is highly corpus-dependent: the optimal representation layer is determined primarily by the source dataset rather than by the SSL architecture itself. Second, the transferred discriminative signal lacks pathological specificity: classifiers trained to detect PD assign similarly high probabilities to both PD and dementia speech in the target corpus. These results highlight critical limitations that must be addressed before speech-based pathology recognition models can be reliably deployed in clinical settings.

S. Kopar, Sam Gijsen, Abner Hernandez et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Beyond Prompt Adherence: Auditing Attribute-Level Voice Control in Speech Generation

Natural-language descriptions have become a flexible interface for controlling generated speech. Existing evaluations largely assess whether an output matches a prompt, but prompt matching alone does not reveal whether characteristics outside the intended change remain stable. We examine this distinction through a controlled paired audit of three speech-generation systems: CosyVoice3, VoxCPM2, and Fish-Speech-S2. The evaluation contains 5,940 outputs spanning six reference speakers, ten texts, three random seeds, and eleven conditions. Using acoustic, prosodic, content, and speaker measurements, we find that responses in the expected target direction are frequently accompanied by changes outside descriptor-specific signal-level target sets. This pattern remains among outputs whose target response exceeds baseline seed variation, and the accompanying changes differ substantially across systems. We further introduce VoDER-Cal, a training-free candidate selector that retains sufficiently strong target responses while favoring smaller off-target deviations. A three-candidate pool raises the joint success rate from 4.8% under single-sample direct generation to approximately 14% for all candidate-selection policies. Within the matched three-candidate budget, VoDER-Cal reduces held-out off-target deviation from 0.344 under target-only selection to 0.276 and improves listener-rated preservation. Preservation-sensitive evaluation therefore complements prompt-adherence evaluation, while candidate reranking offers a practical inference-time improvement. Code, configuration files, and analysis scripts are available at https://github.com/intelland/VoDER

Xianhao Zhou, Jianghao Wu · 0 citations
Preprint Jul 2026

Prosody-driven Jailbreaks in Audio LLMs: A Controlled Study and Mechanistic Analysis

Overall, matched-text speech delivery should be treated as a first-class factor in Audio LLM safety evaluation by holding transcript content fixed and varying six speech-delivery presets whose acoustic attributes may co-vary.

Jiachen Qian, Junyu Li · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

The Learning Objective Governs Perceptual Narrowing: A Cross-Lingual, Layer-Wise, Ten-Seed Study of Self-Supervised Speech Encoders

Perceptual narrowing---the developmental loss of non-native phoneme discrimination in the first year of life \citep{werker1984}---is a canonical developmental finding, yet \emph{what learning objective produces it} remains open. We train a \(\sim\)7\,M-parameter Transformer encoder on child-directed and read speech and evaluate phoneme ABX in English, French, and Mandarin over ten seeds, the seed as the unit of replication. Six results. \textbf{(1)}~The objective sets the direction of cross-lingual transfer: reconstruction (masked mel-prediction) degrades non-native discrimination, prediction (frame-contrastive) improves it---a same-encoder, same-data gap of \(+0.051\) in first-layer Mandarin ABX (\(p=3\times10^{-8}\)), unanimous in sign across twenty runs. \textbf{(2)}~That decline combines a large arm-intrinsic difficulty gradient with a smaller language-specialization effect (matched vs.\ mismatched \(+0.022\), \(p=10^{-4}\), all four layers). \textbf{(3)}~Against a language-symmetric raw-mel floor, reconstruction pushes the first layer \emph{below} the discriminability of its input; prediction pushes it \emph{above}. \textbf{(4)}~Read speech gives a \(3.6\times\) steeper non-native decline than child-directed speech. \textbf{(5)}~The customary three-seed budget cannot see this reliably: an effect unambiguous at ten seeds is called significant by as few as 70\% of three-seed subsets. \textbf{(6)}~Six objective configurations---sharpening, compression, consolidation, their composition, and word-level semantic grounding in two forms---fail to produce the full developmental signature (native improves \emph{and} non-native declines): a single objective moves both languages the same way because it acts on a shared representation. We conclude that the objective, not the architecture, is the first-order determinant of narrowing-shaped representational change.

Sejin Yoo · 0 citations