Skip to content
Book

Academia’s Dilemma

TL;DR

Veteran educator Jo Renee Formicola argues that if higher education is to survive the challenge of artificial intelligence then administrators, staff, faculty, and students have little choice but to cautiously adapt by merging traditional pedagogy with innovative digital tools.

Abstract

Does artificial intelligence replicate human thinking, or just imitate it? How should academia, the epitome of intellectualism, respond to that question and its ramifications for the teaching profession?Veteran educator Jo Renee Formicola argues that if higher education is to survive the challenge of artificial intelligence then administrators, staff, faculty, and students have little choice but to cautiously adapt by merging traditional pedagogy with innovative digital tools. In an age of lucrative business deals, government policies, and pedagogical reforms that hasten institutional change, the value and impact of AI is as easy to overlook as it is to overstate. Amid these conflicting assessments of AI’s role in the teaching-learning continuum, Formicola weighs its value against the power of personal human interaction in the classroom. She examines AI as a worthwhile system to aggregate information and answer difficult research questions, but at the same time a step towards singularity of thought that can circumvent rigorous intellectual questioning and creativity. Blending philosophical insight, pedagogical experience, and timely analysis, Formicola introduces a new framework for teaching that balances technological innovation with emotional intelligence. This book challenges educators and institutions to rethink their reliance on AI and embrace a more relational, student-centered approach to learning.

View source

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Artificial Intelligence in Pedagogy:

The analysis concludes that the future of education lies not in replacing teachers but in developing hybrid models where AI complements human educators, and requires robust ethical guidelines, human-centered design, and policies ensuring equity, transparency, and accountability.

Ravi Kumar, Madhu Mangal Chaturvedi, Reena Kumari · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

To Measure, or Be Measured Unto: What Is Humanism in the Face of Artificial Intelligence? Or: The Instructor Function

This essay contends that artificial intelligence threatens to accelerate the standardization of teaching, diminish faculty autonomy, and redefine education in managerial and technocratic terms, which redefine faculty as an unnecessary expense, and advances an inclusive humanist framework that affirms the intrinsic valu...

Michael Bryson · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

'Sir, will you accept it?': Negotiating AI legitimacy in a university drawing course

This article investigates the negotiation of artistic and evaluative legitimacy following the introduction of generative artificial intelligence (gAI) tools in a university-level drawing course. By examining the lived experiences of ten art education students and three lecturers at the University of Education, Winneba...

Ebenezer Kow Abraham, T. Mensah, E. Buxton · 0 citations
Book Open access Oct 2026

Freirean Perspectives on AI in Education: Emancipation, Knowledge Creation, and Autonomy

With a promise of efficiency-related benefits, Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems are being rapidly integrated into educational practice, be it officially or not. Yet, a growing corpus of research highlights epistemic, pedagogical, and sociotechnical risks, such as bias, hallucination, surveillance, dependency, and t...

Lucas Guarise, Emanuel Felipe Duarte · 0 citations
Review 2026

Artificial Intelligence in Education: Impact on Students’ Critical Thinking, Logical Reasoning, and Cognitive Development: A Comprehensive Review

The CLEAR Framework is proposed, a five-component approach for capturing AI's instructional value without undermining students' cognitive growth, with practical recommendations for educators, curriculum designers, and policymakers navigating AI's growing role in education.

Ashok Sadavare, D. Kumbhar, Aditya Sadavare · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.