Skip to content
Review Open access

B-192: Recent Scientific and Legal Challenges to Performance and Symptom Validity Tests

Oct 2026 · Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology · 0 citations

Abstract

Objective: Recent critiques have challenged the scientific basis of performance validity tests (PVTs), mischaracterizing them as malingering tests and lie detectors. It has also been argued that common PVTs, such as the Test of Memory Malingering and Word Memory Test, are collinear, redundant, and essentially multiple versions of the same test. The current project sought to evaluate the scientific accuracy of these critiques and examine implications for clinical and forensic neuropsychological practice. Method: Recent methodological and scientific critiques of validity indicators were reviewed. Published responses to these critiques were also examined. The legal implications were illustrated through excerpts from a case in which a Daubert challenge sought to exclude expert testimony referencing validity test findings. Particular attention was given to differentiation of validity assessment, malingering determination, and lie detection. Results: Review of the literature identified inaccuracies and areas of overstatement in recent critiques, including the characterization of PVTs as malingering tests and the assertion that frequently used PVTs are redundant due to collinearity. Published methodological responses provide evidence-based support for distinguishing among validity measures and for interpreting findings within a multiple-method assessment framework. A general framework for responding to such critiques is outlined. Conclusions: Recent critiques of PVTs and SVTs may have implications for both scientific practice and the admissibility of neuropsychological testimony. Clear explanation of the scientific basis for validity assessment can help clinicians respond effectively to legal challenges.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Oct 2026

B-195: Validity Testing in Pediatric Intellectual Disability

Objective: This review examined the empirical utility of stand-alone performance validity tests (PVTs), symptom validity tests, and embedded validity indicators in pediatric intellectual disability assessment, with emphasis on their neuropsychological and forensic relevance. Method/Data Selection: A systematic review...

Lindsey R. Adams, Charles Golden, G. Sloan-Peña · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

B-184: Stroop-Based Embedded Indicators of Performance Validity in Veterans

Objective: This study evaluated the Stroop Color-Word Test (SCWT) as an embedded measure of performance validity. Prior studies support several SCWT indicators for detecting invalid test performance in clinical samples. We expanded on prior work by assessing the classification accuracy of established indices in a vet...

Alonzo Howard, K. Bain, J. Marceaux · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

B-171: Constructing Objectivity Under Scrutiny: A Proposed Qualitative Study of Forensic Neuropsychological Report Writing

Objective: The objective of this review is to examine how objectivity is conceptualized and maintained in forensic neuropsychological evaluation, with particular emphasis on the construction of written reports within adversarial legal contexts. Forensic neuropsychologists must translate complex cognitive and behavior...

Payton Lee, Krystal Piumatti, Eric B. Vogel · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Performance and Symptom Validity Testing: Terminology, Conceptualization, Practice Standards, and Future Directions

This commentary summarizes terminology and practice standards for assessing the validity of test scores obtained during neuropsychological evaluations. It also highlights conceptual gaps and emerging directions for improving validity assessment. The process of assessing the accuracy and interpretability of psychometric...

John-Christopher A. Finley, G. W. Kent, Mira I. Leese et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

B-187: Agreement Rates Between an Alternate Cutoff for the Test of Memory Malingering and Other Performance Validity Tests

Objective: Determine concordance rates for Test of Memory Malingering (TOMM) Trial 2 cutoff of ≤ 49 (established by Erdodi & Rai, 2017) and other performance validity tests (PVTs) from multiple cognitive domains. Method/Data Selection: Participants were 137 patients (60.6% female; 63.5% white) that underwent neuropsy...

Craig Stone, Hannah Klingmeyer, Michael S. Daniel et al. · 0 citations
Review Sep 2026

Good intentions but bad outcome: Critique of the Minnesota Neuropsychology Conference proposed guidelines.

Objective: The proposed Minnesota Neuropsychology Conference (MNC) guidelines may become enforceable standards for neuropsychology training. We describe the process and critique the content. Method: Review of the MNC process, proposed guidelines, and related documents. Conclusions: Some assertions in the proposed guide...

Laurence M. Binder, Melissa A. Friedman, W. Milberg et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.