Oct 2026· Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology· Vol 41, pp. ii129-ii130· 0 citations
Abstract
Objective: The objective of this review is to examine how objectivity is conceptualized and maintained in forensic neuropsychological evaluation, with particular emphasis on the construction of written reports within adversarial legal contexts. Forensic neuropsychologists must translate complex cognitive and behavioral data into legally relevant conclusions that are subject to scrutiny by opposing experts, attorneys, and courts. Method/Data Selection: A narrative review of peer-reviewed literature in forensic neuropsychology, forensic psychology, and legal decision-making was conducted. Sources were identified through review of empirical articles, theoretical papers, and professional guidelines, with selection prioritizing work addressing bias, adversarial processes, expert reasoning, and forensic report writing. Informal procedures were used to synthesize relevant conceptual and empirical contributions. Results/Data Synthesis: The literature consistently identifies cognitive bias, adversarial allegiance, retaining-party pressures, and emotional influences as threats to objectivity. Recommended mitigation strategies include structured reasoning, transparency, and deliberate consideration of alternative explanations. However, limited research directly examines how forensic neuropsychologists construct written reports in practice, particularly how evaluative reasoning is translated into a formal document under adversarial scrutiny. Conclusions: The report-writing process represents a critical but underexamined stage of forensic evaluation. Greater empirical attention is needed to understand how evaluators operationalize objectivity in real-world contexts. Qualitative approaches, including semi-structured interviews and conventional content analysis, may provide valuable insight into decision-making and report construction processes in forensic neuropsychological practice.
Objective: Forensic neuropsychological evaluations are conducted within adversarial legal systems in which clinicians produce scientifically grounded opinions under conditions of heightened scrutiny, competing expert interpretations, and high-stakes legal outcomes. Although professional guidelines emphasize objectivi...
Payton Lee, Craig Wetterer· Archives of Clinical Neurops...· 0 citations
BACKGROUND
The assessment of discernment is central to the evaluation of criminal responsibility in forensic psychiatry. However, its conceptual ambiguity and methodological variability raise concerns regarding the reliability and consistency of expert assessments.
OBJECTIVE
This scoping review aims to map how discer...
Nawal Ouhmad, N. Combalbert· International Journal of Law...· 0 citations
Objective: Recent critiques have challenged the scientific basis of performance validity tests (PVTs), mischaracterizing them as malingering tests and lie detectors. It has also been argued that common PVTs, such as the Test of Memory Malingering and Word Memory Test, are collinear, redundant, and essentially multipl...
Jeremy J. Davis, R. Denney, Martin L. Rohling· Archives of Clinical Neurops...· 0 citations
Objective: This case was referred to evaluate competency to stand trial in a defendant presenting with reported cognitive limitations, psychotic symptoms, possible traumatic brain injury, and profound deficits in legal knowledge and engagement with counsel. The referral raised the question of whether the defendant’s...
Payton Lee, Craig Wetterer· Archives of Clinical Neurops...· 0 citations
This paper examines principles of social cognition in forensic psychology, a field that sits at the intersection of psychological science and the justice system. Social cognition—the study of how people perceive, interpret, and respond to others—rests on four pillars: impression formation, stereotypes and prejudice,...
Tess M. S. Neal, Kevin L. Blankenship, Maya A. Irvin-Vitela et al.· Social & Personality Psychol...· 0 citations
Abstract Confirmation bias is the seeking or interpreting of evidence in ways that are partial to existing beliefs, expectations, or hypotheses. Confirmation bias leads to errors due to access to extraneous, contextual information. These errors have caused a significant number of unjust convictions. This article discus...
Phillip J. Resnick, Ashley H. VanDercar· The Journal of legal medicin...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.